Why does creature obey harry potter

He was unkind and short-tempered to him which was rather unlike him I don't hold the view that Sirius's treatment of Snape means he is naturally cruel. Kreacher absolutely doted on Sirius's mother and it makes sense that she might not have been particularly cruel.

Why be cruel to a servant that has been carefully and successfully brainwashed to spout your views? As others have said, even if she was somewhat unkind the expectations of house elves are low. Kreacher went to Bellatrix and Narcissa because they were an extension of his mistress. They may have treated him in varied ways, but especially if they recognised his value then they would certainly have been far kinder than Sirius - and even more pleasant than he was used to.

Narcissa and Bellatrix were in part raised by Kreacher, so harbored a kind of caring that Kreacher recognized. Sirius and Regulus were different, male, and had somewhere learned "empathy" which Kreacher could not understand.

No, they did not physically mistreat the house-elf, but made him do "kind things for others" that were outside of Kreacher's concept base. To him, this was a kind of cruelty, to do things against his nature. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group.

Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. If he has passed into your ownership, he will have to obey. If not, then we shall have to think of some other means of keeping him from his rightful mistress. I mean, think of what might happen if the Malfoys prior to freeing Dobby decided to trade up to an even more oversized and conspicuous manor house. Would they have to leave Dobby behind to spill all their deep dark secrets to the new owners? Okay, just reread the relevant passage in Half-Blood Prince.

Then Dumbledore summons Kreacher and tells Harry,. So at least in this case, the elf does indeed belong to the actual physical house. I actually got kinda misty-eyed during that very scene. At Christmas , Kreacher was in charge of taking gifts from Albus, James, and Rose to Gryffindor Tower and prevent them from trying to open them early. Kreacher also advised the family to contact them through the Floo Network.

Kreacher was extremely devoted to all members of the Black family except Sirius Black, whom he hated. Sirius claimed that he was slightly less devoted to Sirius' father than he was to his mother but also said he caught him snogging a pair of his fathers old trousers. Kreacher was often seen taking orders from a portrait of Sirius' mother. Considering Kreacher was disloyal to people who treated him in a horrible manner, the Black family must have treated him with kindness.

Out of all members of the Black family, Kreacher's bond with Regulus appeared to be the strongest. In fact it was partially because of Kreacher that Regulus turned against Voldemort; after discovering the cruel way his master treated Kreacher, and realising that his immortality came from creating Horcruxes, Regulus and Kreacher went to the cave to steal Voldemort's locket.

Regulus sacrificed himself to retrieve the locket, even though he could have ordered Kreacher to drink the Drink of Despair for him, showing that he truly did care about Kreacher.

The elderly house elf was still devastated by Regulus' death, eighteen years after it happened. He felt he had failed Regulus by being unable to destroy Voldemort's locket. Unlike Regulus, Sirius was horrible to Kreacher, treating him as though he was not worth anything, but also ordering him about. Sirius' behaviour originated from his hatred of his family and the house of Black itself. However Albus Dumbledore said that he was usually kind to house elves.

Kreacher hated Sirius, because of his cruel attitude towards him, and he betrayed Sirius to Bellatrix Lestrange and Narcissa Malfoy which resulted in Sirius' death. For Christmas in , Kreacher gave Harry a box of maggots. Harry showing Regulus Black 's fake locket to Kreacher. Kreacher told Harry, Ron , and Hermione the story of the two lockets and his inability to destroy the real one.

He told Harry that Mundungus Fletcher stole the real locket and Harry rewarded him with Regulus's fake locket for tracking down Mundungus. Kreacher's joy at being given a Black family "heirloom" as his own caused him to drastically change his view of Harry.

He even started to treat Hermione, whom he had previously disdained as a " Mudblood ", a bit better. Hermione turned out to be right about Kreacher; he was nice to those who treat him well. The morning of Harry, Ron, and Hermione's attempt to break into the Ministry of Magic to find the real locket of Salazar Slytherin, Kreacher served them a breakfast of rolls and coffee and promised a meal of steak-and-kidney pie to be waiting for them when they returned, but after successfully obtaining the real locket of and escaping the Ministry, Harry, Ron, and Hermione were no longer able to go back to Grimmauld Place because they let Yaxley inside the Fidelius Charm.

Harry and Hermione concluded that it would be too risky to summon Kreacher since Grimmauld Place was most likely taken over by Death Eaters. Kreacher's whereabouts during the following period is unknown, but it's known that sometime before the Battle of Hogwarts he somehow came to the Hogwarts kitchens. Kreacher led the house-elves of Hogwarts in the final battle against Lord Voldemort and his Death Eaters for Harry Potter , defender of the house-elves, and for the sake of the memory of his long-dead master Regulus, bringing to mind that, although he was a Death Eater , he had died fighting Voldemort.

It is not specified whether he survived the Battle of Hogwarts, but Harry, who wanted to go to bed after the battle, wondered if Kreacher could bring him a sandwich, implying that he did in fact survive. It is unknown if he continued to work in the Hogwarts kitchens or entered the service of the Potter family , or possibly both.

At some point after , Kreacher passed away at age In , the memory of Kreacher was captured by the Calamity and began to appear around the world as a Foundable. Like all house elves, Kreacher was considerably smaller than a human. He was described as having a bulbous, snout-like nose, bloodshot eyes, many folds of skin, and white hair growing out of his bat-like ears. Dobby also knocked out half of his teeth with a punch in , and it is unclear as to whether he had them magically grown back.

Kreacher was very loyal to all the members of the Black family except Sirius Black , whom he hated because he treated Kreacher poorly. He had a strong bond with Sirius' brother, Regulus Black and was devastated by his death. Kreacher was usually hostile, bitter and miserable and had a habit of insulting people, including his masters.

He frequently called Hermione Granger a Mudblood. He loathed taking orders from those he hated, often giving them a dirty look or a biting remark. Like most members of the Black family, Kreacher believed that Muggle-borns and blood traitors were scum.

Because of this, he frequently insulted Hermione even though she tried to be nice to him. However, he gradually grew more respectful towards both Muggle-borns and blood traitors, as is seen by his giving Hermione a respectful salute prior to the infiltration of the Ministry of Magic. Kreacher was also very loyal to people who treated him with kindness and respect, particularly Regulus Black.

However, he was disloyal to those who treated him poorly. This ultimately led to him being partially responsible for the death of Sirius Black. Had Sirius treated Kreacher the same way his brother had, his death could have been avoided. While he assisted Regulus in trying to bring Voldemort down, this did not stop him from assisting the dark lord through Bellatrix and the Malfoys some fifteen years later. Despite this he likely did not see a connection between the two events and merely saw both actions as service to the Black family.

He also didn't seem to hold any resentment towards Voldemort for trying to kill him and showed no hesitation in helping him indirectly by luring Sirius out of hiding. This is presumably due to the way house-elves are generally treated which, as Hermione says, is not much better than what Voldemort did to him. Because of years of solitude, Kreacher hadn't cleaned the Black family home for a long time and when the Order of the Phoenix used it as a headquarters, he was rarely seen cleaning.

He also had a habit of stealing items that reminded him of his loyalty to the Black family. Kreacher was also considered to be slightly mad, probably from being stuck in the Blacks' house alone for so long. His misery and insanity was most probably a combination of drinking the Drink of Despair , Regulus Black's death, not being able to complete his master's order of destroying the locket, living alone with the locket as well as Walburga's portrait, and Sirius Black's cruelty to him.

A tradition for the Black family house elves was for their heads to be cut off and stuck on a plaque. Kreacher and Ron both expressed the wish for this to be done to Kreacher. Ron later regretted this statement.